February 2017. A bumper horse called Samson’s Reach, trained by a yard with zero winners from 88 attempts in the discipline, won at Bangor at 100/1. He was in the notebook. He had been backed on his previous run. And on the day he won, he ran without a mention — no flag, no bet, nothing. This is the story of how a 100/1 winner was identified, backed, and then missed at the moment it mattered. The lesson has not aged a day.
Run 1: The Debut
Run 2: The Bet
The Newbury run was discouraging. The debut had shown a horse with something to work with. Newbury showed a horse that appeared to have nothing. A poor start to the betting year compounded the doubt. When the next entry came, it was easy to let it slide. Too easy.
Run 3: The Miss
The Lesson
The Newbury run was too bad to be true. A horse that stayed on from an unpromising position on debut, for a yard that almost never wins bumpers, does not suddenly become a non-stayer at a flat track. There was every chance the run was an aberration — a bad day, an immature horse not handling the occasion, a jockey who could not get a tune from an inexperienced type. That is what the notebook is for: to hold judgement through the noise and wait for the next opportunity.
The mistake was not backing the horse at Newbury. The mistake was abandoning the thesis after one bad data point. The debut said the horse had ability. The Newbury run said the ability did not show up that day. Those are two different conclusions, and the second one does not cancel the first.
This is the practical application of everything the Five Principles describe. The staking was right. The process was right. The identification was right. What failed was discipline at the third run — the willingness to trust the process when the most recent evidence argued against it. Every serious bettor will face this moment. The ones who stay in the notebook win at 100/1. The ones who flinch watch from the sofa.
The Notebook in Action
Every selection on this site is the product of this process — the reasoning published before the off, the result logged after.
What if the price has shortened by the time I get to it?
Judge it bet by bet. The cleaner the case in the prose, the more decay I'll tolerate. Rule of thumb is about two-thirds of the advised price — 14/1 down to 10/1 is still in, 9/1 down to 6/1 still fine, anything below that is marginal.
Worth knowing: short prices often drift back out as the off approaches, especially on outsiders. Keep checking in the last 20 minutes — you may get back to the advised price or close to it. And always bet with bookmakers offering Best Odds Guaranteed so you're covered if the SP comes back bigger.
Why are some bets win-only and others each-way?
Three things decide it: confidence, race shape, and the betting market.
If I think a horse has an outstanding win chance, I'll back it win-only to maximise the return — even at a bigger price, where each-way would normally be the safer call. If the win case is more speculative but the place case is strong, each-way carries the bet.
Concrete example: Almanack at Kempton, 2 July 2014. Advised at 22/1 win-only in the morning. The price shortened to 16/1 SP and he won by a short head on the line. Win-only on a confident shout at a generous price is where the real returns come from — when the case is right, you back it to win, not to hedge.
What happens if my horse is a non-runner?
If a horse is declared a non-runner before the race, your stake is returned in full on win or each-way singles.
If it's part of a multiple (accumulator, lucky-15, etc), the bet runs on without that leg and the remaining legs are recalculated. For ante-post bets the rules differ — usually no refund unless the bookmaker is offering NRNB ("Non-Runner No Bet") on the race. Full breakdown here.
Why no advised bet some days?
Because there isn't one. The cards don't always offer value, and the worst thing a tipster can do is force a selection just to fill a slot.
A "No Bet" day is the system working — it's the same discipline that produces the winners on the days the bets are right. Better to sit out a card cleanly than to bleed the bank on filler. The best days are usually the ones I've been patient before.
New to this? Read up on: Best Odds Guaranteed · Betting Odds · National Hunt Racing
Get tomorrow's pick before the off
Every selection posted before the race — the angle, the reasoning, the price. Free, no fluff.
